Inside Lightroom

Digital Media | Spotlight: Photography | Inside Lightroom | Blogs

LR2's Adjustment Brush - Observations, Revelations & Evolutions


Lightroom's Adjustment Brush - Observations, Revelations and Evolutions

[Click on photo to enlarge detail]
In the last post I wrote about LR2's Graduated Filter. The other localized editing tool, which many think might be the most significant addition to LR2, is the Adjustment Brush [AB]. The AB (keyboard shortcut "K" in your program) allows you to "paint" localized non-destructive effects like Exposure, Saturation, Sharpness, etc. You can then change or add parameters to the selected area and fine tune the effect to your image.

There have been some complaints about performance issues with the AB. It is a memory hog for sure but the performance issue seems to be system-based and influenced by your graphic card and its settings. That being said, you can't deny the powerful creative localized tool that the AB is, so let's continue…

Evolution #0:

Adding an effect with the AB at times can be challenging, not just because of the performance issue above, but sometimes the effect is hard to notice… especially if the effect is subtle. When I first started using this new AB tool, I would exaggerate the effect: e.g. Exposure -4; Saturation +100; Sharpen +100. Using these exaggerated settings, I could follow creating my AB effect more easily. Once done selecting the area, I would pull back my settings to an image appropriate level. Most of the time this worked but then I had a revelation which I call Evolution #1.

Evolution #1:
{Make and save a custom "Effect" to use when adding an AB selection}


I made a custom effect where I changed only the "Saturation" to -100 which made it very exaggerated. I saved this setting as "BobD [GS]" and used it when adding an AB selection. This was neat because when I used the AB brush with this setting, I actually "painted in grayscale". This was helpful because it was very easy to view the area being created. Once I was done with my selection, I would reset my "Saturation" to 0 (double clicking on the slider's pointer) and, from my growing experience, type in the desired effect… like Exposure = "-.66" (-2/3 stop) or Clarity = 50… or both, etc. This worked out well.

Periodically I would check my selected area by hovering my cursor over the AB "pin". This would show the affected AB area in red. Do to the performance issue stated above, this hovering started to get a little tedious. So, I would press the letter "O" on the keyboard to "toggle" the red color mask on/off. This led me to another revelation, you guessed it - Evolution #2.

Evolution #2: {Paint my selection with the mask area "toggled on"}

Why use my saved desaturated "BobD [GS]" setting at all… why not paint my selection with the red mask "toggled on" by pressing the "O" key before starting my selection! Which I do! This makes it really easy to follow the selected localized correction area. Why, it even makes correcting this area using the erase brush much easier. Well, easier if you weren't painting a red mask on a red apple - very hard to see. (Note: "Quick Tip" below)

The skinny of this evolution is, if you "toggle on" your mask it makes selecting your desired area much easier. Once selected, press "O" to "toggle off" the mask and type in the effect then adjust settings for the current image. Now, this is pretty good but the typing started to get a little repetitive which led me to my next revelation I call Evolution 2a (ok, not such a big change)

Evolution #2a:{Change localized effect with saved presets}

Painting with the mask "toggled" on, I no longer needed my "BobD [GS]"effect, (a.k.a. Evolution #1). However, it did lead me to create other localized Preset effects (more exaggerated than the LR defaults) like, Warm; Cool; Exposure+; Exposure -; Clarity+; Clarity- (Soft Glow); Sharpening+; Sharpening- (Soft Focus); etc.. As in Evolution 2, I paint my localized selection with the mask "toggled on". Now, instead of typing my effect, I simply pull down my list of Presets and selected the desired effect. I then do subtle adjustments for the current image. (BTW, these saved Preset effects are also available when using the Graduated Filter tool.)

Quick Tip: Using AB with the Mask "toggled on"
The clever LR development team anticipated painting a red mask on a red apple. So, by pressing "Shift" + "O" on the keyboard, you will toggle through colors from "red" to "green" to "light gray" to "off" and then back to "red" again. (Watch out for the "off" setting - it is like toggling on an invisible mask, if you stop here… there could be confusion!)

L,O.R.E.
Well, that's it until the next post. In the meantime I will continue working with
Lightroom, Observing Revelations and Evolutions!

<< End >>





AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Comments (8)

8 Comments

Jao said:

I love the adjustment brush and these are some good tips and a great overview of the use of the brush. The overlay view is very useful. Also useful is the "H" key, which hides or shows the pin associated with the brushstrokes. Many times people by accident hit it and then have no idea where their brushstrokes went.

Antonio said:

Great tips! I love the new tools in LR2, although I think I care more for the graduated filter than the adjustment brush. But I have begun using it more and it is growing on me, and these tips will only help that relationship grow!

Thanks & keep it up!

Some excellent tips, Bob! Thanks!

Adjustment brushes really have a lot of power built in. I'll have to explore some more.

Bob D said:

Antonio,

I agree, the AB brush has grown on me the more it improve. I saw and improvement from LR 2.0-2.1 and LR 2.2 claims fixes in performance to the Adjustment Brush. They have addressed the lag in Lightroom performance when applying the adjustment brush with the auto-mask tuned on.

LR 2.2 claims to have addressed other issues with both the Adjustment Brush and Graduated Filter:
- The Adjustment brush created blocky, straight edges to brush strokes under certain conditions
- Lightroom could become unresponsive when using the graduated filter under certain conditions
- It was possible to lose the ability to edit an adjustment brush setting after applying a graduated filter with hidden pins
... We'll see - we can only hope.

Did you see my last post on the graduated filter? (Click Here). My use has evolved there also. I now use a preset to add a "null" gradient to the top or bottom (or both) of my image. Then I add the desired preset (Warm, Cool, Exposure-, etc.) that I mention in this current post. Maybe I'll post these presets on my site for download.

Thanks for the input,
Bob DiNatale

Frank Vetere said:

Great tip as usual, Bob. The adjustment brush performance in LR 2.2 appears to be an improvement. Maybe a little off topic, but would you anticipate any problems with Camera Raw and Photoshop after upgrading to LR 2.2 without upgrading to CS4?

Bob D said:

Frank,

It is my understanding that you do not need ACR 5.2 installed for LR this is just a PS/ACR handshake. ACR 5.2 is incorporated in LR2.2. If you open a LR 2.2 image in PS/CS3 as “Background” there are no consequences. The only consequence is if you open the image from LR2.2 to PS/CS3 as a “smart object” AND tried editing a non 4.6 supported feature in CS3 it would be “unaddressable”. And that news is not all bad because although it is “unaddressable”, it WOULD NOT be altered, removed or destroyed.

If you wanted to alter a 5.2 ACR effect not supported in CS3 then make the change in LR2.2 and reopen it in PS/CS3 again as a “smart object”. You still maintain all the benefits of the “smart object”… non-destructive scaling, adding smart filters, etc.

Bob D said:

jao,

About your comment on the "H" key to hide the pins:
I agree you have to be careful because if you hide them (or press "H" by accident) you have no idea where their brushstrokes... This happened to me and I went so far as to reinstall LR only to rediscover the "H" key!

However, there has been a change. When using the Adjustment Brush, simply moving your cursor off the photo hides the pin. However#2, it does not work the same for the Graduated Filter pins... go figure!

Bob DiNatale

Les said:

Bob,

Another great series of tips. I dunno how you keep coming up with these 'hidden' features. (But maybe it's my fault for not reading all the help files).

Anyway thanks, both your recent your posts have enabled me to get much more out the 'TAT" tools.

Les

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

Recommended for You

Tag Cloud

Stay Connected